Zagg: Premium Crap
31 01 2009When I go buy things, usually, I don’t go by other people’s testimonials – I go out, find something that meets the criteria I’m looking for, and then go and buy it; the entire transaction is pretty quick. In the last ten years, I’ve bought one or two things because people online say that it’s worth the extra money. That was the case with Zagg – a company that makes “high-end” screen covers. With a bunch of devices from here and there in need of covers and armed with a 50% off coupon, I hopped on over to their website and bought five covers for five devices that needed covers:
- My original Apple iPhone.
- My Blackberry 8830.
- A T-Mobile G1.
- A Nokia 5800.
- A Nokia N78.
They arrived about ten days later in a sturdy box with a cryptic mailing label. Before I opened the box, I spent a good ten minutes trying to figure out what was in the box – lest it be the latest anthrax delivery mechanism. I opened the box to find five battered, bruised, and outright crushed boxes, each containing ShieldSPRAY(TM), an Install Squeege and tucked away behind all the marketing, thin bags containing the MILITARY GRADE (O RLY?) screen covers. Well, normally, at least. Two of the boxes had no squeegees, one had no ShieldSPRAY(TM) and in three of the five boxes, the bags containing the screen protectors had fallen out and were sitting on the bottom of the shipping box. Not a promising start, but I thought, hey, what could go wrong? Much, as I was to learn.
- Apple iPhone cover: this was by far the easiest to install. You sprayed on the ShieldSPRAY(TM), a cleaning surfactant/distilled water combination to remove the grease, and stuck the thing on. Took about a minute. However, after I put it on, I discovered that not only was the touchscreen response significantly diminished, glare had increased. Well, I knew that would happen going in, but I had hoped it would be less pronounced an effect.
- Blackberry 8830 cover: try as I might, I couldn’t get the cover to neatly wrap around the top curve of the properly. Either there was a crinkle on the top, or the cover failed to adhere. It was also nigh impossible to remove the little cut-out for the headset speaker. I ended up pulling out an X-Acto knife and trimming the top and cleanly removing the cut-out. Okay, so these things happen.
- T-Mobile G1 cover: The protector adhered reasonably well, with the exception of the fact that it’s about 2-3mm too long and thus sticks out. Again, note the diminished response and glare issues. There’s also a weird… texture to the material and thus it looks like your screen is underwater.
- Nokia 5800 cover: This is where the disaster really began. It’s clear that Zagg did not just not bother to measure the screen size (or curvature!) correctly, they also didn’t consider the problem caused by trying to give a single piece for the screen; net result: the bottom area, around the buttons, simply doesn’t fit, with giant air bubbles. Part of the problem arises from Zagg’s screen cover material – it’s slightly stretchy, which means that when you follow their directions and attempt to squeeze the bubbles out, you end up stretching the material out. There’s also no appropriate tool provided for these narrow edges, and while installing, you live in perpetual fear of tearing the thing. Hey Zagg, how about measuring the things you’re selling fitted covers for?
- Nokia N78 cover: I don’t have a cover on it. Not because Zagg didn’t ship the item, but because the cover’s adhesive refused to adhere to anything – EXCEPT the tissue you are forced to use to clean off the excess liquid SpraySHIELD(TM) if you follow their directions. I ended up tossing it out after 15 minutes of trying to get the tissue material off the screen.
So, what’s the verdict? Let’s give the Apple iPhone full marks, the 8830 a half mark and the T-Mobile G1 a 3/4. The Nokia covers, both of them, were FAILs. The 5800 cover, I’ll generously give a zero to; the N78, though, is a -1. Total score? 1.25/5. I’d also deduct points for their environmental friendliness if I weren’t in a good mood – I have five four squeegees, five three bottles of ShieldSPRAY(TM) (of which, less than a third of one bottle was used), and five paperback-book sized crushed boxes. Hey Zagg, if you’re shipping an order all together, send only ONE of the squeegees and ShieldSPRAY(TM) and all the screen covers together, in a CRUSH-RESISTANT box. Had I been shopping around in person and seen the crushed boxes, I would’ve skipped your company all together, figuring you’d rather make a couple of extra bucks than ship a decent product.
Verdict: Zagg – selling premium crap to suckers who shop at Sharper Image since 2005. Avoid.
Categories : annoyances, gadgets




